Menu Icon

Looking for homebrewing gift ideas? Check out our previous gift guides here or here!
Also, if you enjoy BrewUnited, please consider doing your Amazon shopping via our affiliate link!

Transition to AG brewing and Recipe Design (Part 3)

Posted by xnoom on 11/04/2016 at 03:57:19 AM


Part 1, Part 2

Brew 9: First Recipe: Pale Ale

After doing research on recipe design (primarily by reading Designing Great Beers and Brewing Classic Styles, and following the /r/homebrewing Tuesday recipe critique threads), I was ready for my first attempt at recipe.  Following feedback from a discussion thread, I settled on this recipe.

After multiple glowing reviews of the brew bag, I decided to get one, not being a huge fan of the vorlauf step (a few husks always managed to get through).

I can highly recommend this approach, as it cuts a good deal of time from the brewday with no perceived downside (by me, at least).

Brew day went mostly smoothly, other than a slightly low mash temp (1-2 degrees).



After bringing down the temperature a bit, I tried pushing ice water through the chiller with the pump from my keg washer.

I switched away from ground water too soon… I ran out of ice before it was chilled all the way.

I was able to get the temperature lower than I had with my warm groundwater though, down to ~70.

Beersmith predicted this beer would finish at 1.012, but it actually came in at 1.006 (88% apparent attenuation).  I was worried that this indicated infection, but a search shows many other people online reporting similar attenuation with 1056.  It was somewhat lacking in body, perhaps from the over attenuation.  There was a lot of pleasant hop aroma from the citra, and a nice smooth bitterness, but very minimal honey taste from the honey malt.

My initial impression was that the beer was good, but not exactly what I was expecting.  I got happier with this the more I had it though… once I stopped being overly-critical, I was able to appreciate it as a good beer.  It was very refreshing, and in particular it was great when mixed 4-5:1 grapefruit soda.

Perhaps even more importantly, I finally managed to get to the bottom of the off taste in my first pour after reading through this thread.  I ditched my original lines and went with Ultra Barrier Silver PVC Free, and the taste was finally gone!

Brew 10: Second Recipe: Brown Ale

My second recipe was a brown ale, taking inspiration from Caribou Slobber mixed with recipes in Brewing Classic Styles and Designing Great Beers.

I tried recirculated ice water through the chiller again, and made it much simpler by adding some quick connects.  It worked much better this time… I didn’t switch until the temperature had gotten closer to 100, and I actually ended up below pitching temp by a couple degrees.


I picked up a Beerbug, as I was interested to see the progress of fermentation.  I also had to pick up a stopper, as Beerbug fits a standard airlock opening, and Speidel has a larger one.

Unfortunately, this was a nice waste of money, as the Beerbug is now no more than an expensive paperweight.

Before their site went AWOL, I had mixed feelings… it seemed to be more sensitive to temperature changes than a hydrometer, and read quite a bit lower than the gravity reading taken at kegging time.  However, it tracked the progress of fermentation well, and showed clearly when it was complete.

I hope a better product comes along to take its place (Tilt, anyone?)



The beer came out with a nice chocolatey taste, but maybe a touch too sweet.  At first I thought it was very slightly fruity (possibly from the yeast), but that dissipated a bit as it aged.

I didn’t get much of the nutty taste I’ve read from Golden Naked Oats, so I may not have added enough (or may have chosen a beer with too many other flavors).  It had great mouthfeel, coming off as almost creamy.

Brew 11: Third Recipe: Sorta NEIPA

I had recently come across New England IPAs… and having no easy access to the style on the west coast, I thought it would be interesting to give it a try.  After reading some general IPA advice and getting some feedback, I put together this recipe... since I hadn’t had one though, I was a bit hesitant to go all the way with it, so I went a little light on the oats and kept the sulfate:chloride a touch above 1:1.

I also decided to try malt conditioning while lowering my mill gap to 035”.  This turned out to be a terrible idea, as my mill completely jammed (even after raising the gap back to .040”). I had not previously had problems with a cordless drill… this time though, I ended up having to grab a corded drill from the neighbors to get through the grain.

Afterwards though, the brew itself was mostly uneventful… mash temp came in a bit low (possibly because of colder outside temps).  Efficiencies were close, and FG was just a touch low.

This beer came out very good, though I can’t really say how close it is to a real NEIPA.

It had a super strong fruity aroma which persisted even after more than a month in the keg (I like to hope at least partially because of the closed transfers...), and amazing head retention.

There was moderate bitterness on the front, and just a very slight lingering grassy taste on the back, possibly from the large dry hop.

The lighting in the picture makes it look darker than it actually was; it was much more orangey looking in person.

While it was quite tasty, I didn’t quite pull off the creamy mouthfeel… probably because I hadn’t completely followed the recommendations for oats and water chemistry.


Brew 12: Fourth Recipe: Oatmeal Stout


For my last brew as part of this misadventure, I decided to put together an oatmeal stout recipe.  

I unfortunately don’t have much in the way of pictures, as I just had to pick the one day during the year that it rains in Southern California, so I had to rush to get everything under a canopy.

I neglected to take a picture of the beer itself, so you’ll have to take my word that it definitely looked like a stout.

The brew day went fairly smoothly.  After my ill-advised malt conditioning attempt, I tried leaving the mill gap at .035” and picking up a corded drill, which made it significantly easier to mill at a lower more consistent speed.  Possibly as a result, my brewhouse efficiencies bumped up to about 70%, a neighborhood I’ve been able to stay in consistently since.

I didn’t read up on toasting of oats ahead of time, so I missed the general recommendation of toasting them several days in advance and placing them in a paper bag, and instead ended up toasting them morning of.  This was my only time making this beer, but I didn’t detect any harsh character from this though.  The beer came out very smooth and chocolatey (maybe even a bit too much, I might up the amount of roast barley next time).

Final Thoughts

I enjoyed this process a ton going through it, and I’ve since continued to delve further into recipe design, small batch testing, and moar gear.  Looking back, it was a bit daunting to make the leap, especially as someone who tends to over-research and over-prepare for things (spending time researching 3-vessel HERMS/RIMS or water chemistry before ever doing all-grain is probably not a great idea…).

After actually making a couple batches though, it’s really not so tough.  Breaking things down and focusing on a minimal amount of changes at a time really helps to understand the effects, and reduce possibility for mistakes.

Tags for this post: all grain, equipment, transition, brewing

Please log in to comment on this post
Don't have an account?